Overall a good book. I agree with some reviews that this wasn't an overly exciting installment however there were some very important things going on. I know a lot has happened to Laney since she met Oliver and I'm betting there is more to come. I was happy to see her step out of the "i need to do everything Oliver tells me to" role for a bit and it seems she is having some very conflicting feelings about a number of the relationships she has. I am interested to see where the story goes as it felt like it ended somewhat abruptly (although that could just be because i was looking for more of a forward progression with Laney and Oliver). I will definitely read the next book and hope we get more of the story behind the rest of Laney's family (father, grandparents, etc.)Overall i would give 3.5 if allowed.